Forum archives » Read My Damn Comics » An Old Noob

pinkyswear
August 13, 2009 5:11 PM

I got an account here on Stripcreator only a few days ago even though I was actually introduced more than three years ago.  In those years of which I was aware of this website I've discovered that it attracts a very, for lack of a better word, interesting crowd.  Now I am curious as to how this crowd will take in my inadvanced humor.

Haha, ok, that's not actually how I speak.  It was just for a good first impression.  But the facts are all true.

Here's a taste of my style:

/comics/pinkyswear/471336/ 

/comics/pinkyswear/471337/

/comics/pinkyswear/471347/ 

/comics/pinkyswear/471350/ 

Dialogue-Free:

/comics/pinkyswear/471348/ 

Please advise. 

Post #272771link

Injokester
August 13, 2009 9:39 PM

Friday Night Pizza: I can see what you were going for, but it kinda bombed. Would have worked well with a really suspenseful setting that implies a life changing decision.
Spinning in Death's Chair: This one I liked, though the execution could be better. The robot makes no sense, and the title is too obvious (same with the first strip for that matter).
The Magic of Fabric: Also liked this one, the characters work in well with the joke. I'd have left out the ", ok?" at the end though to make things more definite, but your call.
Fatter, Too: Pretty sure I've seen this joke before, possibly even made it myself (or at least something very similar).
It's Not Fair To The Other Reindeer: This also feels like an old joke.
Speed is Everything: Excellent strip, well delivered, doesn't waste words and a solid gag.
This Trash Can Only Holds One: This one is so ludicrous it made me laugh pretty hard :)
Your Time is Up: Pretty meh.
It's Coming: Another gem, using different poses on Melvin gives the impression he's literally making an effort to grow a beard, that's what sold it for me :)

Overall a very decent start - don't be discouraged that some of these didn't land - writing humour takes practice to get right. Some good ones in there too, showing some definite potential. Keep it up :)

Post #272774link

attitudechicka
August 14, 2009 6:22 AM

Friday Night Pizza: I agree with InJokester on this one. I also wouldn't have titled it "Friday Night Pizza" as it kind of ruins the punchline.
Spinning in Death's Chair: I giggled a little.
The Magic of Fabric: Even with InJokester's suggestion, I still would not find this funny. Different strokes, I suppose.
Fatter, Too: I also do not find this funny.
It's Not Fair To The Other Reindeer: I agree with Injokester - changing poses are often over used. Even by me.

In general (I was going to say "overall", but I feel like InJokester's parrot right now), I look forward to more strips from you and quite enjoy your style.

Post #272775link

pinkyswear
August 14, 2009 7:41 AM

Thanks for the critiques, guys.  I appreciate the tips(:

Friday Night Pizza: I really liked the idea of having it take place in a more suspenseful setting.  Thanks.

Spinning in Death's Chair: The robot was supposed to be the reaper's minion, but I guess I sort of screwed that impression up. I should've written "I wonder what the boss is doing in there..." instead. 

The Magic of Fabric: I didn't do so well on the wording.

Fatter, Too: Don't recall having seen this joke recently, but I might've run across it earlier on.  I'll try to avoid these situations.

It's Not Fair to the Other Reindeer: This one was done more on impulse, and I don't think I did such a good job either.

There's not much to reply to for the other ones, but thanks for telling me why you liked a comic rather than just saying it was good(:

I'll use better titles next time, too.

Post #272778link

pinkyswear
August 14, 2009 9:46 AM

Here's a new one.  What do you guys think?

/comics/pinkyswear/471597/

Post #272779link

evil_d
August 14, 2009 10:45 AM

quote:

pinkyswear wrote:
Spinning in Death's Chair: The robot was supposed to be the reaper's minion, but I guess I sort of screwed that impression up. I should've written "I wonder what the boss is doing in there..." instead.

But still, why does the reaper have a robot for a minion? 

I don't understand what's going on in "It's Not Fair..." (or maybe I do, but I don't see how the title's relevant) or in "Just an Everyday Quarrel".

My favorites were "This Trash Can..." (more silly than funny, but that's not a bad thing) and "It's Coming!"

You seem like the sort of person who thinks before he types, and lord knows we always need more of that.  Welcome aboard. 

Post #272782link

pinkyswear
August 14, 2009 12:09 PM

Well, I couldn't exactly pick which character would stand outside the reaper's door, and it somehow ended up being the robot.

For the "It's Not Fair to the Other Reindeer" comic, Rudolph is the only one with a red nose, so I just assumed that's how the title would relate to the comic...

I don't blame you for not understanding the "Everyday Quarrel" comic.  I think I just did bad on the executioning.  The surgeon in the last panel  is not the same surgeon that was speaking to Melvin.  He's the one that the surgeon in the first and second panel was referring to when he said "You should've seen the other guy."  I hope that clears things up.  Sorry.

 

Post #272784link

pinkyswear
August 14, 2009 1:46 PM

/comics/pinkyswear/471607/

Some way to improve?

Post #272789link

FactoryRejects
August 14, 2009 2:52 PM

That new one is okay for cute, g-rated humor.  I think you should've used the title as the punchline though; having the little girl ask the Amish guy if she can go pee.

Post #272791link

pinkyswear
August 14, 2009 3:17 PM

Hmm yeah, I guess that would've been better.

How about this one?

/comics/pinkyswear/471612/

Post #272792link

pinkyswear
August 16, 2009 3:26 PM

/comics/pinkyswear/471817/

Post #272811link

xxausrottenxx
August 16, 2009 4:29 PM

ha!

Post #272812link

pinkyswear
August 16, 2009 6:43 PM

Post #272814link

AngryAmerican
August 18, 2009 1:42 PM

Some of the humor seems to fall into the Family Circus-style 'aww, that's cute' category, which sickens me.

I'm an adult, which means I prefer R rated stuff.

If you want your light to be seen, you have to take it into dark places.

Post #272842link

Scyess
August 19, 2009 12:07 PM

Solipsism, eh?

Post #272854link

pinkyswear
August 19, 2009 3:49 PM

AngryAmerican - I'll try to avoid that from now on.

Scyess - Loved it.  Especially the last one.

Post #272859link

pinkyswear
August 19, 2009 4:43 PM

Post #272861link

biped
August 20, 2009 12:36 PM

The reaper one is funnier WITH the robot. 

With the robot not saying ANYTHING. 

That's my advice.

Post #272870link

Injokester
August 20, 2009 5:47 PM

quote:

biped wrote:

The reaper one is funnier WITH the robot. 

With the robot not saying ANYTHING. 

That's my advice.


Heh, that could actually work. Granted it's pretty random and I'm a hell random mood, so dunno how well it'd land.

Personally I'd have replaced the robot with Jesus saying something like "Dad? Dad can I come in? I know you're busy with universes to create and all, but I need to talk to you about something important. Dad?" And then had God inside instead of the reaper.

Post #272871link

pinkyswear
August 20, 2009 7:29 PM

Ha!  I like both of those ideas!  Thanks for the tips(:

Post #272873link

Forum archives » Read My Damn Comics » An Old Noob

stripcreator
Make a comic
Forums
featuring
diesel sweeties
jerkcity
exploding dog
goats
ko fight club
penny arcade
chopping block
also
Brad Sucks