**ahem**
Superman has other weaknesses, just his most widely known happens to be the rock. (He is vulnerable, for example, to magic.)
As for the X-Men, one reason I never followed their comics on a regular basis, is for the reason Josh stated: There's just too blasted many of them. I picked up a friend's book once and got about two panels in before I had to ask her, "What the heck is he talking about here?" She then went into a thirty-minute explanation of this character's history with another character (which confused me, since she spoke in terms of OTHER events I had no knowledge of) and the current situation in relation. Two more panels, and I nearly asked the question again -- only I figured if I wanted to actually *read* the book that night, I was going to have to do so utterly clueless.
It's okay -- I like the "main" characters (the ones featured on Fox's animated series and in the movie). I don't even mind when they make guest appearances in Spidey (which happens infrequently, sadly), because individual characters are interesting. It's the X-books as a whole that frighten me.
Batman is a neat character for who he is, but sadly he'd stand no chance against the kinds of villains that Spidey , Supes and the X-folks have to fight on a regular basis. Still, he has his own demons to fight, not to mention that sometimes he acts as if he himself belongs in Arkham. He's an interesting character study, and his abilities are indeed formidable -- but he's just not on par with the others.
This is a fun discussion -- and for once, I even know whereof I speak! -- I hope it doesn't degenerate into a " is better and sucks" type argument.
Hey Josh, I'm curious to know -- You mentioned Dick Grayson (who is no longer a 12-year-old circus performer) as Robin... what did you think of the late Jason Todd, and the latest Robin, Tim Drake? (I briefly collected Robin, but had to drop it once it started tying in too tightly with the other Bat-books -- limited funds, you know...)
---
This is not my empire.