Forum archives » Fights Go Here » News and Classrooms

Spankling
January 22, 2004 9:27 PM

It occurs to me that two discussions that have been going on are essentially related, though each group sees the reverse side as reasonable on each issue. I am okay with college professors engaging students in political discourse, even to the extent of stating their preference, but I hate biased news media - people lying or reporting only certain stories and pretending to be fair and balanced. Other people (and I probably will not do their argument justice) suggest that a slant to the news is inevitable, but that professors are wasting class time and undermining the learning process when adding opinion to lecture.

Of course, I'm right and they're wrong. But I welcome discussion on the matter being a liberal and all. ;-)

Post #119411link

ObiJo
January 22, 2004 10:25 PM

Well I believe everything that comes out of a human beings mouth is opinion. There's a probability it's true and a probability that it's false. Both probabilities existing at the same time. People can't make their opinion fact no matter how hard they believe it or how much they want others to.

If everyone realized/believed that, there'd be no problem. Students in classrooms would assign the teacher's opinion to the teacher himself instead of solely to the issue. If Mr. Jones says, "Republicans are greedy," or Ms. Smith says, "Democrats are naive," the student would assign values as such: Mr. Jones + Republicans = value assignment of greedy to Republicans by Mr. Jones. And: Ms. Smith + Democrats = value assignment of naive to Democrates by Ms. Smith.

Or put more simply, your opinion says as much about you as it does about that which your opinion is "about". You + Thing = Opinion.

And like I said, if people realized this, all would be good. Biased teachers could say whatever they want and biased news organizations could do the same. But most people don't do this. They assign the value to the concept itself without filtering it through the person. They minus out the "You" in You + Thing = Opinion.

So, accepting that most people are like this, and assuming you adopt the ethics of equality, I think it's important for teachers and news organizations to either withhold their biases and present both sides (near impossible for many people) or they ADMIT to being biased and have somebody biased in the opposite direction given equal time. ie, they admit that they're applying a good-bad value system to the phenomenon rather than just reporting what is and give someone with a different view equal time.

In the classroom, that can be accomplished by promoting classroom discussion. To be effective, this would require the teacher to again dismiss the absolutism of their good-bad value system, and encourage the equality of opinion in their classroom whether or not it disagrees with their personal value system. Also, this would require the teacher to enforce this equality of opinion among his/her students, regardless if the opinion's split 50/50, or 99/1.

In the media, you could also go the "equal time" route, though I'd *like* to see more observational reporting. With observational reporting you'd have news agencies reporting WHAT'S happening. "This bill was passed, this congressman stepped down, etc." Whenever WHY it's happening is approached, you present both sides. Whenever you approach how it will affect such and such, or in fact whenever you approach anything to do with value judgments, you present both sides.

The ABSOLUTE WORST thing is to have single-sided value-judgement reporting presented as observational reporting. For me, this is the fastest way to lose legitimacy as an attempted reporter of truth, whether you're a teacher OR a news organization.

Post #119418link

Spankling
January 22, 2004 10:32 PM

quote:
To be effective, this would require the teacher to again dismiss the absolutism of their good-bad value system, and encourage the equality of opinion in their classroom whether or not it disagrees with their personal value system. Also, this would require the teacher to enforce this equality of opinion among his/her students, regardless if the opinion's split 50/50, or 99/1.
Agreed. Damn - no argument. This is also how the teachers I remember did things. The ones that were hose bags and tried to swagger and strut and act like they knew god personally never got me to come to class on a regular basis. Schooling is a hi-priced commodity and I only paid for what I thought was worth while.

Post #119419link

ObiJo
January 22, 2004 10:49 PM

Whereas I was a little grade whore. : )

Post #119423link

boorite
January 23, 2004 8:58 AM

When you're reporting social, political, or psychological phenomena, there is no such thing as no bias.

Post #119462link

ObiJo
January 23, 2004 10:34 PM

But there is the attempt.

Post #119660link

Forum archives » Fights Go Here » News and Classrooms

stripcreator
Make a comic
Forums
featuring
diesel sweeties
jerkcity
exploding dog
goats
ko fight club
penny arcade
chopping block
also
Brad Sucks