Everyone else seems to be posting an opinion, so I guess I will too.
[u]DexX[/u]: Sure, he's grumpy sometimes, as he himself admits. But it's really nothing compared to some of the jerks I've met online. And I think his track record (partly detailed above) shows that his heart's in the right place.
[u]dorkrod[/u]: I believe he's a lurker. And no, that doesn't have any bearing on whether he's right or not. But let's suppose I regularly use my telescope to spy on the people who live across the street. Do you think they'll let me have a say in which type of wallpaper they should put up? Dorkrod's statements are matters of opinion, and frankly, if you don't participate in a community, you can't expect its members to care about your opinion on their internal affairs.
[u]Nate[/u]: When I was his age, I got into worse arguments than these all the time. Thankfully, since then I've learned some things which I trust he'll learn in the not-too-distant future. I don't think he should leave. I do think he should try to develop his skills in the areas of (a) choosing his battles and (b) having a solid argument ready. If he has better evidence to support his claim that Catholics aren't Christians, I think he should share it. I also think some people around here could stand to be more patient with him.
---
The what mentioned above is total fiction. Please don't take it seriously!