Important notice about the future of Stripcreator (Updated: May 2nd, 2023)

stripcreator forums
Jump to:

Stripcreator » Regarding Stripcreator » rating system

Author

Message

hog
Stripcreator Newbie

Some kind of rating system would be really cool, like if you could rate that person's comics out of five or ten, and then they would get a rating based on the average, on how good thier comics are. Unless it would totally kill bandwidth and then it wouldn't be so cool any more.

6-19-03 12:50pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Brad
Feature Creep

Member Rated:

I have been giving more and more thought to putting one of these back in, though I'm not quite sure if it's worth it.

---
www.bradsucks.net

6-19-03 1:38pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


MaKK_BeNN
VOTE JEB BUSH 2008

Member Rated:

What if you did a ranking system like google, that ranked people based on the number of other strippers who linked them. You could maybe use date and activity of the accounts linking them to weed out people making fake accounts to up their rating.

---
Vote Jeb Bush 2008

6-19-03 4:14pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


boinky33
I'm with stupid ^

Member Rated:

I think a rating system would be keen.

6-19-03 4:19pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


evil_d
Riding through your town with his head on fire

Member Rated:

My opposition to reimplementation of a rating system is abating, especially if it would turn out to be a convenient non-confrontational way for the community to tell people they suck. Just do it right this time!

---
The what mentioned above is total fiction. Please don't take it seriously!

6-19-03 5:56pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Drexle
Your Cure for Lameness

Member Rated:

Perhaps you could rig it to where only registered user's votes are the ones that count for an actual score that's displayed to the public? Votes cast by non-registered users could be delivered to the individual user, but not displayed. This would prevent people from cheating on their ratings to boost themselves up or tear someone else down.

Additionally, perhaps each registered user could only set one vote per strip, but that vote could be changed at the user's whim?

6-19-03 6:50pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Devin
Comic Overlord

Member Rated:

Make it so that you have to vote with your name (no votes unless you're logged in) and let people see who voted how.

And if we only allow the author to see the rating of his/her comics, that should take care of any of that rating boosting/killing problem.

6-19-03 7:08pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


hog
Stripcreator Newbie

Member Rated:

See, I'm new at this and never knew that there was a rating system. It would make sense if you had to log in, for obvious reasons. Newgrounds has a good rating system, from what I've seen.

6-19-03 10:08pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


TheElPaso
Senior Comic Technician

Member Rated:

If comics were only allowed to be rated from random.php, then cheating goes down the shitter, but I'm not sure if anyone would want to be able to do so from anywhere else, or if anyone even wants some form of high score list at all. Just throwing out ideas.

---
My love for you is like diarrhea, I just can't hold it in. -Weird Al Yankovic

6-20-03 12:11am (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


umfumdisi
Forum comment:

Member Rated:

ooh, ooh, and make it where, like, when I vote and stuff, the uh, the uh, good ratings symbol appears as one of the, uh, asian girls, and the bad rating symbol is, errrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.........., Tobor--yeah.

OOH, and whenever I ping Brad on IRC, make him bring me a pizza!

Come on, people, give Brad a break.

---
Chicken Feather Bed Bugs Bunny Hop Sing Out Side Street Walker Texas Ranger Cookie Dough Boy Wonder Years

6-20-03 12:39pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


boinky33
I'm with stupid ^

Member Rated:

No.

6-20-03 2:23pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


TheElPaso
Senior Comic Technician

Member Rated:

It's been way over thirty minutes since umfumdisi requested that pizza, Brad. Now it's free.

---
My love for you is like diarrhea, I just can't hold it in. -Weird Al Yankovic

6-20-03 2:41pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


KajunFirefly
chooby digital (in stereo)

Member Rated:

I don't need brad to program a new ratings system to know how awesome I am.

You post comics, people tell you that you're awesome, end of story.

Although, I have become more aware of my awesomeness since the PM system became available, so I'm not necessarily against the idea.

---
Dad was flammable

6-20-03 3:47pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


MaKK_BeNN
VOTE JEB BUSH 2008

Member Rated:

I don't think it'd be an issue of how awesome people are. Like the internet, stripcreator has a bunch of crap on it, and it'd be a good filtering system for the stuff that isn't crap for new users.

---
Vote Jeb Bush 2008

6-20-03 5:10pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Bargaintuan
Don't eat any wooden nickels.

Member Rated:

It would be cool if Stripcreator could have a list of the top rated strippers and/or comics, too.

---
Life is a lot like getting mugged; you get your kicks, you take your punches, and when it's over, someone else gets your cash.

6-20-03 10:36pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


boinky33
I'm with stupid ^

Member Rated:

yes. we should also have casual fridays.

6-20-03 10:42pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


kaufman
Director of Cats

Member Rated:

And flowing rivers of chocolate.

---
ken.kaufman@gmail.com

6-21-03 8:08am (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Devin
Comic Overlord

Member Rated:

quote:
I don't need brad to program a new ratings system to know how awesome I am.

You post comics, people tell you that you're awesome, end of story.


Ha! I'm so awesome, I don't even BOTHER to post comics!

But really, it's because I'm afraid of rejection.

Oh my god, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, NO! If you do that, there'll be LOTS of incentives for rating abuse!

6-21-03 9:39am (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Brad
Feature Creep

Member Rated:

I think I can make a system that's much better than the previous crappy one, but it's always going to be vulnerable to abuse. I can't stop people from making multiple accounts so it's unlikely I can stop people from boosting their ratings artificially.

---
www.bradsucks.net

6-21-03 10:53pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Bargaintuan
Don't eat any wooden nickels.

Member Rated:

You could make it weight votes by how many comics each user has made at the time of the voting, under the theory that people that make comics know comics.

---
Life is a lot like getting mugged; you get your kicks, you take your punches, and when it's over, someone else gets your cash.

6-22-03 12:18am (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Devin
Comic Overlord

Member Rated:

Make the ratings private so only the author can see them.

6-22-03 9:24pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


TheElPaso
Senior Comic Technician

Member Rated:

Then insert a top 50 comics page, and only put my comics on it.

---
My love for you is like diarrhea, I just can't hold it in. -Weird Al Yankovic

6-22-03 9:25pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


MaKK_BeNN
VOTE JEB BUSH 2008

Member Rated:

What if you take the motive out of cheating the system? Just make it possible to sort things by a few criteria.

Maybe by "most comics made"
And by "linked to the most number of people"
And I don't know maybe "alphabetical order"
And maybe by date of account created

So it's all quantitative and not qualitative.

The only people who would be think about cheating the system are these complete freaks who count their number of posts and love getting comics that end in all zeros or are perfect squares or whatever. And if they need to try and get the most number of comics posted..well..isn't that so sad that it would be cruel to take that fun away from them?

btw congratulations to boinky33 for getting to 1000 comics!

---
Vote Jeb Bush 2008

6-22-03 11:20pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Bargaintuan
Don't eat any wooden nickels.

Member Rated:

It would be cool to have a "Most Favoritest Strippers" list, which would be strippers listed by the number of favorites lists they're on. Still subject to cheating, but maybe you could weed the cheats out by inactivity.

---
Life is a lot like getting mugged; you get your kicks, you take your punches, and when it's over, someone else gets your cash.

6-23-03 12:31am (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


KajunFirefly
chooby digital (in stereo)

Member Rated:



*cough*

To be honest, I don't think it really matters how people tell me and their friends that I'm awesome, just that they do.

---
Dad was flammable

6-23-03 2:11pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info

Stripcreator » Regarding Stripcreator » rating system


reload page with comics

Jump to:

Post A Reply


stripcreator
Make a comic
Your comics
Log in
Create account
Forums
Help
comics
Random Comic
Comic Contests
Sets
All Comics
Search
featuring
diesel sweeties
jerkcity
exploding dog
goats
ko fight club
penny arcade
chopping block
also
Brad Sucks