quote:
quote:
It did not come across as a friendly debate or sharing of ideas/experiences, it comes across as "I boorite,think this is bunk,
therefore, I'll tear apart everyone's statement and throw it back at them."
More like, I, boorite, suspect this is bunk, or rather that there is a rational explanation for these things, and therefore I'll tear apart the claims and throw them back at you to see how you stick them back together, and we'll do this back and forth and maybe in the process get close to the truth. Your characterization was fairly close, though! You say it like it's a bad thing.
Precisely! "Tearing apart everyone's statement" is just a pejorative term for logicially assessing a person's beliefs and finding them wanting.
I've seen many cases where the logically defeated have nothing left to attack but the manner of the person who defeated them: for example, over here, the banning of foxhunting has been attacked by its opponents as a waste of parliamentary time which could be better spent on other things. Having been talked into a logical corner, they have to fall back on miserable retorts like that. I'm not morally equating the hunting lobby with the supernaturalists or anything: it's just a convenient comparison.
Nor am I saying that boorite has defeated the supernaturalists (doing so in a few messageboard posts would be quite a feat), but his arguments have been pretty lucid and rational. Replying to them with accusations of smugness does the other side no favours. If his contribution has seemed a bit arrogant, well, see past it and put forward counter-arguments. The rational will always seem arrogant compared to the irrational, even though, as boorite says, it's far more arrogant to cling to your own ingrained beliefs in the face of reason. We should not "accept that we know nothing": rather, we should strive to know more.
Anyway, some of these stories are pretty disturbing, particualry DexX's. My own isn't as dramatic as these, but I thought I'd subject you to it anyway...
The thing with the cats isn't the only mysterious event I've seen. Oh, no. When I was a nipper, I was on "holiday" with my family in a cottage in the Highlands. One night, I was coming down the staircase, when, through the glass door, I saw an old woman, just standing there looking into the house. My parents and sister, the only other people in the house, were in the front room. We were miles from anything resembling civilisation. The nearest road was on the other side of a large valley.
Is anyone still reading this, by the way?
It's strange, but I don't recall feeling unnerved at the time: perhaps the unknown is scarier when reported than when witnessed. After sitting on the stairs for *several minutes* looking at this person, who remained motionless and expressionless, I went to the front room and alerted my mum, who looked out the door. True to cliche, the apparition was gone.
Thinking about it now, it's not really *that* weird. It would be an odd thing to do, but I suppose someone could've just walked over here in pitch darkness and decided to peer into the house. Nonetheless, it's something I've never forgotten.
Oh, and once Charlie Chaplin and Elvis appeared in my room. But that's pretty commonplace.