quote:
You must have done a lot of heroin before seeing Mononoke Hime to think it was emotionally cold. It's my 2nd favorite of Miyazaki's (after Nausicaa). But I suspect we have different taste in Miyazaki, because I found Kiki to be boring -- nothing really happened in the movie after the beginning. It was just a series of trivialities.
But it was much better than Umi ga Kikoeru, which was a high-school melodramatic series of trivialities.
Ok, give me a break, I rushed out that post in a hurry with a stomach that was growling for food. I do know one reason I was less than impressed with the film is that I saw the dubbed version. I still can't get the voice of Jiko (Billie Bob Thornton) out of my head. If I saw the subbed version, I'm sure I would think better of the film.
I will say the film is subtle and nuanced. In general, the characters are neither totally good or bad. Case in point, Lady Eboshi, who is both destroying the environment and acting as the protector of prostitutes and lepers. San has a sharp edge to her personality that makes it harder to empathize with her as compared to the other Miyazaki heroines. Mononoke Hime is the strongest of Studio Ghibli's films about the environment (ex. Nausicaa, Pom Poko). Speaking of which I never have seen Nausicaa in it's original form, only as the Warriors of the Wind. Perhaps that is another film that I need to rescreen.
Concerning Umi ga Kikoeru, I've never had the (dis)pleasure. I have heard the same thing said about Whisper of the Heart, and I'd agree. But I don't mind a movie that involves life's trivialities as long as the characterization is strong and the situations in the film add to the character development. For example a really bad slice of life anime that I saw recently was NeiA Under Seven. That was a whole lotta nothing going nowhere.
I see that I'm going to have to borrow a friend's copy of Mononoke Hime and see it again. Maybe there is a way to burn out Billie Bob's twank out of my brain.
---
"Nothing expresses the brutal grandeur of rectal polyps and anal fistulae quite like the mother-tongue of Goethe."