Comics involving the Amish and/or Cthulhu:

Amish Rake Fight and The Rylyeh Chronicles

What about an Amish Cthulu?

Can An Extraterrestial God Even GROW A Beard? by ArtemisStrong 12-20-03

Well, foul human usurper? Let's go over this again: Barn-raising involves a lot more raising of barns and a lot, a LOT, less disembowelling innocents. I'm a Deep One, foolish mortal. Human flesh is to me like a pinata filled with corn chowder is to an eight-year-old reveller. Well, if you want to do this right, you're gonna have to listen to me. 'Kay? You're making me eldritch. You wouldn't like me when I'm eldritch. What the hell is an eldri- Hey! Stop vivisecting my abdomen!

---
Ham-fisted ham fisting.

!

---
...and pain joined his urge to percieve...