I find it hilarious how a comic that is initially rated GOOD by a bunch of people suddenly takes a dramatic nosedive after it's been in the Top 5 for a short time.

It's not necessarily 'sour grapes because I've seen it with other strippers comics in the past and have wonder why the comic hasn't stayed in the top?

An example is I had 6 votes and a 10 rating which put me on top....suddenly the next 6 votes bring the average down by half? Furthermore, why did people suddenly even CARE enough to rate this particular comic when there are many other comics I have created that they could have rated (good OR bad?)

So, what's going on?

1) Different senses of humour (absolutely possible)
or 2) downvoting at it's best.

My guess is the latter and preservation of the current top rated comics.

Thoughts? Am I wrong in this or has anybody else noticed this phenomenon?

Yes, this happens to me pretty often.  Recently I had the top two comics, both rated 10, and before long they were on page four or five where my top-rated comics can usually be found.

---
Legend, oh legend, the third wheel legend...always in the way.

I think some donors cruise the toprated page every now and then simply to downvote anything that gets a 10. I don't know why, but that is always the case.

---
It was such a waste of everyone’s time and money that even the Tokyo stadium’s rape robots apologized– something they were programmed specifically never to do.

Cre8tive13

Which comic is it?  Maybe the six people who would normally read your comics because they think they're funny liked it, when in reality it's crap that was exposed when it the top rated list.

 Whip it out!

---
peddling the funny around since 09/24/2002

not_Scyess

Which comic is it?  Maybe the six people who would normally read your comics because they think they're funny liked it, when in reality it's crap that was exposed when it the top rated list.

 Whip it out!

I'm going to say that Scyess is probably right on the money with what happened to your comics. The same thing happens to mine alot. I accept the fact that some people like my comics and others don't. The toprated list doesn't really mean anything since the same comics have held the top spots forever. It really is pointless to care about. It's just as bad as whinning about how many stars you have.

I just rated them all bad.

---
Batman created by Bob Kane

I also rate everything bad, just hoping people will start whinning about it. I do feed off of all your misery you know.

I'm sure it's a combination of both, but who knows what the ratio is.

I read toprated weekly or so to see what's new, and I give each comic a fair shake. About every three months, I go through every page and give each comic a rating. Over time, I'm sure my opinion of what's good/okay/bad has changed, but in general, I don't base my rating decisions on "is this the best comic on the site and therefore deserving of appearing on the first toprated page?" If I think it's good, I'll rate it as such and I don't really care if a comic I think isn't that great is rated higher than one I do or one of mine--humor is all relative. Also, in those instances, I'm certain someone else will downvote it, so I may as well vote it good if I think it's better than okay.

I rarely vote comics bad that I discover first on toprated, but it happens. I have a pretty narrow definition for what I think is bad in the toprated arena, so I probably give more okays to comics that I think aren't good. I think in the first ten or so pages, I average 1-5 okay ratings per page.

Here's what I think when one of my comics appears at the top: "Cool, four people who like my comics liked this one enough to rate it." Then I know that people who don't think I'm the funniest human on the planet will start voting it down. It's okay--I realize I'm not for everyone. Dcom has told me several times that I keep telling the same three jokes over and over and over. Anyway, that's more or less what's happening to other users--their fans put them at the top, then the people who think the user isn't that great knock it down either for pure or impure reasons.

Glad someone brought this up, as I've been wondering about it as well. I think it's also worth mentioning that some people (like me) may just not choose to rate badly a comic they don't like which is not on the top comic list, but believe it deserves a fair look, for positive or negative, once it's up there. For instance, I used to work with a guy who admitted liking young(ish) girls. I didn't turn him in then, but when he becomes senator, it's zoom-lens time.

crabby

I'll never understand why so many people seem to think whining is such a bad thing.

---
Legend, oh legend, the third wheel legend...always in the way.

dcomposed
You'd be the last person in here I'd ever expect anything different from...or care about.

Consider yourself rated bad then fella.

i generally dont look at the toprated much, i have one in there somewhere around page 41 or something, but when i do i find they've been voted good for a reason and usually add another 'good' rating to them.

it doesn't seem like people vote on individual comics all that much cuz otherwise my 'doc pembroke: sexual veternarian' series would obviously be at least on page 30, if not page 25...

---
Kill Whitey.

crabby

I was talking to Dcom...pal.

I"m not 'whining' as Crabby puts it....It was an observation and wondered what everybody thought the reasoning behind why a lot of comics don't stay highly rated for too long.

Like most people here, I'm appreciative that some people enjoy some of my comics enough to rate it good or okay and to make a comment telling me so.

Thanks to those who are adding 'valuable' input to this thread.

Consider yourself rated bad then fella.

crabby

Likewise.

If I hadn't had you rated bad since five days after you got here I'd be doing it now.

---
Batman created by Bob Kane

dcomposed

Oh, I'm crushed...cuz you are one of my favourites.

I said this a few years ago and it still holds true:

When I first came to SC I was so intimidated. But after a few rounds of pitch and catch, I really felt broken in. I was such a good catcher! I even received a merit badge. Seriously, your mothers a whore.

Any who, there is a constant cycle that you have to come to terms with. First, you must pimp yourself out for any recognition or consideration. Initially you will get beat down like the red headed stepchild that my friend is. The best that you can expect? Meh.

Second? The few good strips that you have slowly get rated. SLOWLY mind you. Often times the GODS that be find it beneath them to rate any newbie. Now you’re moving up!

Got three votes and your on the pending list, drinks for everyone! You're a fat cat. Finally, you get that fourth vote that ushers you up to the highest echelon. Sweet Jesus the air smells great! Life is good. Tell your friends how funny and talented you are. Write home to grandma. Bask in the glory that will be swiftly ripped out of your heart. Because as soon as it’s known that a strip is rated a 9 or 10, that same strip will be promptly kicked in the junk and dropped like a herpes laden mug.

But don't mind me, I have yet to pass the third step in the Tony Robbins pyramid of success.

---
obscenity filter is off

I never look at the top rated. If you guys ever see one of my comics as number one, tell me it is before you vote it down so I can take a screenshot of it to add to my scrapbook. I've already done this once because I knew it just wouldn't last.

And by the way, whatever happened to weighted ratings? This way a comic with a high score but a low number of votes wouldn't peak at number one, gaining unwanted attention from sore-loser regs. Besides, what really deserves the number one spot more anyway? a comic with a perfect score but only four votes, or a comic with a 8.2 and over 30? With a more complex ranking system we can easily stop the hate.

---
It's grime time.

---
the kid's getting old, the kid's getting old

LuckyGuess

That post is a cheese log.

---
It was such a waste of everyone’s time and money that even the Tokyo stadium’s rape robots apologized– something they were programmed specifically never to do.

This is Mister Cheese Log.

---
Legend, oh legend, the third wheel legend...always in the way.

i think some of it is downvoting, just like the xenophobic forum downvoting of new people that dare speak. but i think the rest of it is just different senses of humor. some of the comics consistently toward the top of toprated i don't find funny at all, while others on page 8 or not on toprated at all i find the funniest on the site. the trick is not to care and just write what you find funny, but no one every listens when i say this so i'll change it and say the trick is to suck on my prickly nutsack while i jack off to episodes of Ghost Whisperer

---
what if nigger meant kite

I usually check the first 2-3 pages of top rated every few days and vote for anything I haven't voted on yet. I don't downvote. If somethin's funny, I vote it funny, if not, I usually vote "okay." I really only vote bad if I have no fucking idea what the hell's going on in the strip.

---
I has a flavor!