Personally, I think it's a good idea that it takes several votes to get on the list. But the good point is also a drawback, since people have to remember a strip and then go and purposely vote for it. I'm still amazed that The Really Predictable Adventures of Captain Obvious and The Ducks Only Club aren't on the list.
Also, there's the fact that we could all turn out to have totally different senses of humor, even if we want to get more strips on the list. I've been rereading the CCs, since I don't have enough time to look through anybody's entire archive.
---
"Only things I approve of should exist." -some guy on the internet